Here I go again…

Reflections through Pontifications

An Inconvenient Youth

with 6 comments

Teach children the path to follow, and even when they are old, they will not stray from it. (Proverbs 22:6)

Childhood indoctrination.  It’s a dirty word.  Hitler did it.  Stalin did it.  It can never happen here in the free world, now can it?  Of course not.

In the past few days, I have had a couple of disturbing conversations about AGW with the younger generation, including my own daughter.  Particularly striking is the one I had with the 12-year old daughter of a friend.

(Warning: The following transcript may incite anger in libertarians and parents).

Dee:  So, do you believe in Global Warming?

Melissa: Oh, yes!

Dee: Oh? Do you think that people are responsible?

Melissa: Uh huh. They put all that junk in the air and it has to be causing the world to get warmer.

Dee: Is that so? That junk is called carbon dioxide and of all the carbon dioxide that is going into the air, how much of it do you think that people are adding?

Melissa: I dunno… Maybe 75 percent?

Dee: 75%? What if I told you it was less than 5% and the rest was all natural?

Melissa: Well how about all the polar bears that are drowning? The ice cap is melting.

Dee: Ummmm… How many polar bears have drowned?

Melissa: I dunno, but they’re going extinct.

Dee: Oh, really? Polar bear population had doubled in the last few of decades.

Melissa: You are making me mad.

Dee: Why is that?

Melissa: Cause you are.

Dee: OK, so where did you learn that the polar bears are dying?

Melissa: A movie they showed at the school.

Well, gentle readers, I knew to which movie she was referring: Al Gore’s Oscar winning documentary, An Inconvenient Truth. In fact, I was there that day when the school’s earth science class sponsored a public showing and did my best to correct some of the more glaring errors made by Mr. Gore, but it seems that I failed in my task.

To this day, the indoctrination continues to warp the opinions of children too young to understand the science or politics behind AGW and who only care about the cute, cuddly polar bears having to swim 50 or more miles between melting ice flows just to stay alive.

Our Friend, the Polar Bear

Recently, the American Institute for Public Service, a national foundation that honors community service, recognized Cool the Earth for the efforts to educate the youth of the San Francisco Bay Area about the dangers of Global Warming. The founder of Cool the Earth, Carleen Cullen had this to say:

“What I love about working with young people is their absolute optimism,” said Cullen. “You tell them, ‘Hey, we’ve got this little problem over here with our friend, the polar bear, and with humans as well,’ and they’re not overwhelmed by it; they’re not skeptical or cynical. They just ask, ‘What can I do to fix it?’ “

Read the entire article at the SF Chronicle here: Carleen Cullen fights global warming or see it for yourself at Cool the Earth.

P.S. I haven’t given up hope for Melissa – she is a bright kid. I am planning on making a special middle school-level presentation to help her understand both sides of the debate so she can make up her own mind. Who knows, perhaps I can shame the school into letting a skeptic have equal time.

Update (9/10/08): I spoke with Melissa tonight and she is quite excited that an essay about her is so popular that Google ranked it in the top 10 out of 1.2 million hits for ‘Inconvenient Youth’. This seems to have spurred her into digging into the facts behind AGW to see the truth for herself.

On the other hand, in that same search, I found a video posted just this week which was also entitled “An Inconvenient Youth” and is of an 8-year old boy with a message for politicians to stop global warming. I am very sure he didn’t just come up with this on his own. Judge for yourself:

An Inconvenient Youth from Colin McCullough on Vimeo.

Originally Posted at Watts Up with That? – An Inconvenient Youth on Sept 8th 2008


Written by Dee Norris

September 8, 2008 at 3:18 am

6 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. I agree it’s important to give kids two sides of a story/situation to analyze and then make up their own minds. But I never see a problem with taking extra care with the environment, even if the whole global warming issue may not be as urgent as it is being portrayed. I’m not sure if you disagree with the latter, but I just felt like putting it out there.


    October 6, 2008 at 3:01 pm

  2. I believe “global warming” is just one part of a vast scheme. Not just for politics, but for something greater (or worse). Specific industries are capitalizing on this. Plain and simple: It’s a way to make money, the most effective way to maxamize incomes of the super wealthy while they think up the next “brilliant idea.” I have not done much research, yet I am to believe that the poles (polar icecaps?) may be shifting. This is possibly the cause of all our abnormal weather we’ve been experiencing.

    The auto-industry and politics are just two of the very blatant beneficiaries from this claim.

    However, like meekins stated, “But I never see a problem with taking extra care with the environment, even if the whole global warming issue may not be as urgent as it is being portrayed.”


    October 6, 2008 at 3:42 pm

  3. I would be very pleased to hear your more than qualified response to the possibility I presented. If you could post it somewhere on my page so I am notified that would be greatly appreciated!!!


    Reply – This article originally appeared at Watt’s Up With That and there are over 150 comments associated with this post. Perhaps you would like to read some of my responses there and select some that you feel are fitting for your blog. – Dee


    October 6, 2008 at 3:45 pm

  4. I think the real problem is not with teaching environmental sensitivity, but with using manipulation and fear to indoctrinate the children into accepting AGW at face value.

    Dee Norris

    October 6, 2008 at 3:46 pm

  5. Do you really think we should be encouraging a 12 year old child to “make up her own mind” about such a technical subject? Knowledgeable scientists in relevant areas disagree. The best we can hope for from anyone who is not a knowledgeable scientist in a relevant area is to read enough (and it doesn’t take very much) to realize that knowledgeable scientists in relevant areas disagree.

    Reply –
    Wouldn’t deciding that no one really knows why the Earth warms and cools be ‘making up her own mind’? – Dee


    October 6, 2008 at 9:02 pm

  6. dee loved your satire i was onto it early on ,and had a great laugh was also reading a site asking people to only breath 8 times per minute,therefore bringing down the amount of carbon dioxide entering the atmosphere,i was wondering if you could do a piece to convince all politicians to try this out as a show piece to the rest of the planet,or they could hold their breath till they either get their way or…sadly expire trying,but that could be a positive to ,as their carbon foot print would completely disapear up their own back sides.


    October 7, 2008 at 11:23 am

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: